Verse 1 Nineteen in a white sundress, Thought your hands could fix my world. You were older, knew the ending, I was just a hopeful girl. Summer tasted like gasoline, Lipstick stains and motel keys. Every promise sounded heaven-sent, Even when it stole from me. Pre-Chorus Well, I guess I don’t believe it like I used to. You said we’re forever, but forever ain’t that long. God, I wish I could capture it all Inside this song. Chorus The things that I felt for you never felt wrong, Now I feel so stupid for loving you so long. You were my religion, my beautiful mistake, A dream that disappeared the moment I awoke. I still look for us in every setting sun, Trying to find the girl I was before you were gone. If this is how forever ends, Why did forever feel so strong?